Should You Keep Investing in Your Underperforming Mutual Fund?

November 21, 2026

0 Comments

Should You Keep Investing in Your Underperforming Mutual Fund?
It is natural to find a fund lagging the market in your investment portfolio someday. Naturally, you will be disappointed, look for new funds, and wonder whether your money is better invested somewhere else.
However, underperformance is not unusual in mutual fund investing. Different investment strategies perform differently across market cycles. A fund may lag during certain market conditions and recover when market trends change. What matters is whether the underperformance is temporary, arising from the fund's investment strategy and prevailing market conditions, or whether it reflects deeper problems with its management, portfolio or investment approach.

Before deciding to continue, pause or switch your investment, it is important to understand the reasons behind the underperformance.

Do Not Make a Premature Judgment

One of the most common mistakes investors make is judging a mutual fund based on a short period of underperformance. Financial markets are cyclical, and different investment styles move in and out of favour over time.

For instance, a value-investing mutual fund may underperform during periods when growth stocks dominate the market. However, it may perform better when market leadership shifts towards undervalued companies. Investors who rush to exit such funds during a temporary slowdown may miss a potential recovery and end up investing in funds that have already delivered strong recent returns. This behaviour is commonly known as performance chasing.

Investors should evaluate equity mutual funds over an appropriate investment horizon and across different market conditions rather than relying solely on short-term returns. Examining performance over one, three and five years can provide a broader perspective. However, no fixed waiting period applies to every fund. Persistent underperformance or a significant change in the fund's investment strategy may require an earlier review.

Use the Right Measuring Stick

Without a yardstick, a return figure would mean nothing. It could be considered disappointing to learn that an investment fund made 8% in a year until one discovers that its benchmark made only 6%. Conversely, an investment fund could perform quite well if its benchmark is much higher. An investment fund must also be compared to a proper benchmark, which is the appropriate index for that fund. If the investment fund is a large-cap fund, it must be compared to an index covering all large caps like the Nifty 50, while the small-cap fund must be measured against the small-cap index. The index stated by the fund itself is the first thing to consider when comparing.
The second comparison should be done among the funds within the same category because a large-cap fund is supposed to be compared to other large-cap funds and not to mid-cap or debt funds. A multi-level approach to comparison is best suited in this case: is the fund underperforming its category average, and is the category itself performing poorly compared to its benchmark? If your fund ranks low among its peers when examined at the one-year, three-year, and five-year horizons, then the problem becomes more urgent. This is important because funds that underperform in the first case but outperform in the second provide a very different picture than funds that do not perform well in either case.

Check the Fund's Alpha Across Different Time Periods

Another important parameter to examine is the fund's Alpha, which indicates how much additional return a fund has generated over and above its benchmark on a risk-adjusted basis. Investors should review the fund's Alpha across different periods, particularly one-year, three-year and five-year horizons, rather than relying on a single period.

If a fund consistently reports negative Alpha across all these periods, it indicates that it has failed to generate positive excess returns over its benchmark after adjusting for risk. Such persistent underperformance warrants a closer review of the fund's investment strategy, portfolio composition and management.

If the trend continues and the fund no longer meets the investor's requirements, discontinuing further investments or considering an alternative scheme may be appropriate. However, negative Alpha should be assessed alongside other performance indicators and the fund's investment objectives rather than treated as an automatic reason to exit.

Determine Whether There’s an Explanation for Underperformance

Performance statistics can help investors identify a problem, but they rarely explain why it has occurred. Before making a decision, it is important to understand the reasons behind the underperformance.

First, underperformance could simply be part of a well-defined investment strategy. A fund that follows a value-oriented approach, for example, may lag behind its benchmark when growth stocks dominate the market. Comparing its performance without considering its investment philosophy may lead to an incomplete assessment.
Secondly, underperformance could be structural. The fund’s portfolio could deviate from what you have initially invested in: it could be highly concentrated in several companies or sectors, or could consist of stocks in a certain market sector that you have never wanted to invest in. Over-cashing, wrong stock selection, and a series of bad decisions are other kinds of problems with different consequences. The most important thing is to understand whether your initial investment thesis remains valid. If you have decided to buy this fund for its diversified large-cap exposure, and it does not provide it anymore, you should consider changing your investment strategy.

Examine the Fund Manager, the Expenses, and the Risk

Fund management also requires scrutiny. The appointment of a new fund manager does not necessarily indicate trouble or guarantee better performance. However, it may bring changes in investment philosophy, stock selection and portfolio construction.
Investors should examine the new manager's experience, track record in managing similar schemes and any significant changes in the fund's portfolio following the appointment.
Cost is another important consideration. A fund's expense ratio directly affects the returns received by investors over time. Investors should compare the expense ratio with similar schemes and evaluate whether the costs are justified by the fund's performance and investment management approach.
It is also worth checking whether the investment is in a Direct or Regular plan. Both plans follow the same investment strategy and hold the same underlying portfolio, but their expense ratios differ. Direct plans generally have lower expenses because they do not include distributor commissions.
Most importantly, never examine returns without considering the risks taken to generate them. Two funds may deliver similar returns but experience significantly different levels of volatility and losses along the way.
Investors can examine factors such as volatility, maximum drawdown and downside performance to understand how a fund behaves during market declines. A fund that experiences relatively lower volatility and smaller declines may be more suitable for certain investors than one that delivers higher returns with substantially greater risk. However, lower volatility does not mean that an equity mutual fund offers capital protection.

Consider Your Overall Portfolio and Financial Goals

A mutual fund should not be evaluated in isolation. Its suitability also depends on the investor's financial goals, investment horizon, risk profile and overall portfolio allocation.
For example, an investor may already have considerable exposure to large-cap stocks through other mutual funds. Continuing to invest in another large-cap fund may increase portfolio overlap without providing meaningful diversification.
Similarly, a fund that has underperformed recently may still play an important role in balancing the investor's overall portfolio.
Before deciding to retain or replace a fund, investors should consider:
●  Whether the fund continues to align with their financial goals.
●  Whether its risk level is appropriate for their risk profile.
●  Whether its investment horizon matches the time available to achieve their goals.
●  Whether it creates unnecessary overlap or concentration with other investments.
●  Whether the overall equity and debt allocation remains appropriate.

The objective should not simply be to hold the best-performing funds but to maintain a portfolio that is aligned with the investor's financial needs and long-term objectives.

Should You Hold, Pause or Switch Your Investment?

If the review reveals that a fund consistently underperforms its benchmark and peers, has deviated from its investment strategy or no longer meets the investor's requirements, it may be worth considering a change.
However, stopping a Systematic Investment Plan (SIP) and redeeming existing investments are two different decisions.
An investor may choose to pause or stop future SIP instalments while retaining existing holdings until a detailed review is completed. Alternatively, the investor may continue the SIP if the fund's investment strategy remains suitable and the underperformance is considered temporary.
Do not continue investing simply because money has already been invested in the scheme. Similarly, redeeming existing units solely because of recent poor returns may not be the right decision.
Before redeeming or switching investments, investors should consider the applicable exit load and tax implications. Exit loads vary across schemes and depend on the applicable holding period. Tax treatment also depends on the fund's classification, acquisition date, holding period and prevailing tax provisions.
When selecting an alternative fund, investors should focus on consistency, investment strategy, risk, expenses and suitability rather than choosing a scheme solely because it delivered the highest returns during the previous year. Past performance does not guarantee future results.

Conclusion

Continuing to hold an underperforming mutual fund is neither necessarily a good decision nor a bad one. It depends on the reasons behind the underperformance and whether the fund continues to serve its intended purpose in the investor's portfolio.
If the fund has underperformed temporarily due to market conditions, its investment strategy remains intact, and its risk and portfolio composition are still acceptable, continuing the investment may be reasonable.
However, persistent and unexplained underperformance, significant changes in investment strategy, deteriorating portfolio quality or a mismatch with financial goals may indicate that it is time to reconsider the investment.

Ultimately, the decision to continue, pause or switch a mutual fund should be based on a comprehensive evaluation rather than short-term returns or market sentiment. Regular portfolio reviews and a clear understanding of investment objectives can help investors make more informed decisions and stay focused on their long-term financial goals.

Share With

Leave a Reply

This is a standard alert.

I'm a cool paragraph that lives inside of an even cooler modal. Wins!

This is a standard alert.

I'm a cool paragraph that lives inside of an even cooler modal. Wins!

https://scores.gov.in

Thank You

All your Questions have been recorded


Thank You

All your Questions have been recorded

Please enter your name Please enter valid name
Please enter your Email Id Please enter valid Email Id
Please enter your mobile number Please enter valid mobile number Please enter your mobile number Please enter valid mobile number
Please enter your Email Please enter valid Email

Thank You!


Thank you for your response. We'll get in touch with you at the earlisest for your investment planning needs


NEXT

Thank You!


Thank You for your interest in our Moderate Equity Portfolio. Please find below the credentials to track this portfolio:

User ID: mockmod@daycoindia.com

Password: abcd@1234


Portfolio Tracker

Please Read!


Risk profiling is crucial for identifying and managing potential risks in investment decisions. Please carry out your risk profiling before making any investment decisions.


Complete Risk Assessment Now

Set Your Goal

Please Select an option from below


Set Your Goal

Please Select an option from below


Set your Goal

Please enter your details in the fields provided

Please enter phone number / UGC